End of the road for driver sacked for refusing to answer questions

An employee sacked after refusing to answer his employer's questions about competing business interests has lost his Federal Court full court challenge to his failed unfair dismissal bid.

Justices Peter Gray, Shane Marshall and Mordy Bromberg held that "even if it be recognised" that Fair Work Australia "might have viewed" the facts of the case differently and "might have found there was no valid reason for dismissing the [the employee] on the basis that he had failed to respond to inquiries about his business interests", that was not a ground on which the court could overturn the decision.

Any error in fact-finding or reasoning by FWA was "not a jurisdictional error, but is an error within jurisdiction", they said, and it was not open to the court to take a different view to Fair Work Australia of the facts, or of the conclusions drawn from the facts.

"It follows that there was no jurisdictional error on the part of the Commissioner, or on the part of the Full Bench in refusing permission to appeal," they held.

They dismissed the sacked employee's application for a review of the full bench decision and ordered him pay his employer's costs.

Holcim (Australia) Pty Ltd sacked the truck driver after he repeatedly refused to answer questions - put to him and to his solicitor - about its concerns that he had a financial interest in a concrete agitator truck doing work for a competitor, which it maintained was in breach of its code of conduct.

When the matter went before Fair Work Australia, Commissioner Anne Gooley found there had been no breach of the driver's common law obligation to avoid conflicts between his personal interests and his employers, and that any breach of the company's code of conduct was inadvertent.

However, she found - in a decision upheld by a full bench of the tribunal - that Holcim was entitled to ask the driver the questions it did and to require him to respond, and that the employee was "wrong in concluding that his business dealings were none of Holcim's business".

Circumstances where the employer had a genuine, "albeit arguably misguided", concern about a potential conflict of interest and the employee refused to respond to those concerns led to a conclusion that there was a valid reason for the termination of the driver's employment, she held.

Villani v Holcim (Australia) Pty Ltd [2011] FCAFC 155 (2 December 2011)

Did you miss...

$20K-plus costs bill for Gather Round lawyer

A sacked solicitor who claimed sick leave while interstate watching AFL games with friends must pay more than $22,000 in legal costs, after providing false evidence and AI-assisted "fictional" or irrelevant authorities in pursuing his unfair dismissal claim. more

FWC to hear government HR manager's case

In a significant ruling on the FWC's jurisdictional reach, a HR manager has been given the all-clear to contest her sacking by Queensland Treasury after the State accepted it misled a member over the tribunal's powers to deal with state system employees. more

Bill extends NSW IRC appointment limits

New South Wales' Minns Government has introduced legislation it says will "ensure that the Industrial Relations Commission has the people, powers and practical arrangements needed to do its work properly", largely by making it easier to make acting appointments that can last for longer. more

Accountant bitten by short-term voluntary pay cut

An accountant who took a temporary $40,000 pay cut to help colleagues keep their jobs during a downturn has exceeded the high-income threshold for protection against unfair dismissal because of extra payments he later received to "recoup" the money. more