Workplace remark about transgender worker not vilification: Tribunal

A NSW tribunal has dismissed a transgender road worker's allegation that he was unlawfully vilified by comments in the workplace, ruling that the conduct wasn't a "public act" under the state's Anti-Discrimination Act.

One employee allegedly made a remark to another employee of Statewide Traffic Control about the female-to-male transgender crew leader.

The employee was upset that a "trannie" was working for the company and said to her co-worker: "It's a fucking trannie taking hormones but still got tits and a box. I'll fucking punch its head through its car window, cunt".

The co-worker was the only person who heard the remark.

When the crew leader heard about the remark, he reported it to the company's HR department, which investigated the matter and eventually dismissed the perpetrator.

The Administrative Decisions Tribunal full bench – Judicial Member Robertson Wright SC and Non-Judicial Members Anthea Lowe and Jennifer Newman - said that while the employee’s actions were capable of inciting hatred and serious contempt against the transgender person, the claim couldn't proceed as the conversation was a private discussion between the two workers, even though it was conducted in a public place.

The bench said that if the conversation had been a "public act" under s38S(1), it "could be seen as tending to encourage members of the public who heard the comments to treat transgender persons as less than fully human and to suggest that physical abuse of such persons was justifiable".

It said the comments encouraged the view that the transgender worker was "in reality no more than hormones and some body parts rather than a complete human being entitled to the dignity and respect that that entails".

If the act had been public, the bench said it would have concluded "that the conduct was capable of inciting hatred towards and serious contempt for a person on the ground that the person is a transgender person".

It said the purpose of the Act's anti-vilification provisions was to reduce the incidence of physical and verbal violence and abuse against certain groups – including transgender persons – "without at the same time unduly restricting the rights of members of society to hold and express views including those which are unpopular or which some might find offensive".

Barry v Futter [2011] NSWADT 205 (30 August 2011)

Did you miss...

$20K-plus costs bill for Gather Round lawyer

A sacked solicitor who claimed sick leave while interstate watching AFL games with friends must pay more than $22,000 in legal costs, after providing false evidence and AI-assisted "fictional" or irrelevant authorities in pursuing his unfair dismissal claim. more

FWC to hear government HR manager's case

In a significant ruling on the FWC's jurisdictional reach, a HR manager has been given the all-clear to contest her sacking by Queensland Treasury after the State accepted it misled a member over the tribunal's powers to deal with state system employees. more

Bill extends NSW IRC appointment limits

New South Wales' Minns Government has introduced legislation it says will "ensure that the Industrial Relations Commission has the people, powers and practical arrangements needed to do its work properly", largely by making it easier to make acting appointments that can last for longer. more

Accountant bitten by short-term voluntary pay cut

An accountant who took a temporary $40,000 pay cut to help colleagues keep their jobs during a downturn has exceeded the high-income threshold for protection against unfair dismissal because of extra payments he later received to "recoup" the money. more