Discrimination exemption for "pink army" of handywomen

A company that sends handywomen into the homes of vulnerable women has won the right to exclude men when recruiting workers.

The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal granted Pink Army Handywomen a two-year exemption from provisions of the State's Anti-Discrimination Act that prohibit sex discrimination in the areas of pre-work, work and advertising.

The Pink Army's proprietors told Tribunal member Peta Stilgoe they offered "all female" handyperson services to people – such as victims of male-on-female domestic violence - who don't want male workers in their homes.

They said they sought the exemption so they could expand their business by advertising for female employees and contractors.

Member Stilgoe found that the company targeted female and perhaps some male customers "who may not be comfortable with other males in their homes, even for the limited purpose of effecting repairs".

She said she wasn't convinced by the proprietors' argument that an exemption was necessary to provide a service for vulnerable women, as they could "employ whoever is best for the job and simply not send a male to a job if the client so requests".

Member Stilgoe continued that an exemption application shouldn't be granted for "mere convenience or reputation" and said the application conveyed to her a sense – which she hoped was misconceived - that the proprietors "would simply prefer not to employ men".

However, she granted the exemption on the basis that it would promote employment of females in the handyperson/construction industry, after accepting the proprietors' evidence that women make up only 1.6% of tradespeople in the state's construction industry.

Member Stilgoe said that if it wasn't for the tribunal and its predecessors granting sex discrimination exemptions for employment of a podiatrist, a dance instructor and female-only gym facilities, she would not have been inclined to follow suit.

The "limited" two-year term of the exemption would give the proprietors the chance to gather evidence to justify a longer-term exemption, she said.

Pink Army Handywomen [2011] QCAT 39 (10 August 2011)

Did you miss...

$20K-plus costs bill for Gather Round lawyer

A sacked solicitor who claimed sick leave while interstate watching AFL games with friends must pay more than $22,000 in legal costs, after providing false evidence and AI-assisted "fictional" or irrelevant authorities in pursuing his unfair dismissal claim. more

FWC to hear government HR manager's case

In a significant ruling on the FWC's jurisdictional reach, a HR manager has been given the all-clear to contest her sacking by Queensland Treasury after the State accepted it misled a member over the tribunal's powers to deal with state system employees. more

Bill extends NSW IRC appointment limits

New South Wales' Minns Government has introduced legislation it says will "ensure that the Industrial Relations Commission has the people, powers and practical arrangements needed to do its work properly", largely by making it easier to make acting appointments that can last for longer. more

Accountant bitten by short-term voluntary pay cut

An accountant who took a temporary $40,000 pay cut to help colleagues keep their jobs during a downturn has exceeded the high-income threshold for protection against unfair dismissal because of extra payments he later received to "recoup" the money. more