Ashurst refused leave to appear in dismissal case

Last month's Warrell v Walton Federal Court judgment has had immediate repercussions for legal representation in the Fair Work Commission, with major law firm Ashurst thrown out of an unfair dismissal case yesterday.

Commissioner Ian Cambridge followed Justice Geoffrey Flick's decision (see Related Article) in refusing leave for the law firm to represent Serco Sodexo Defence Services in the case, finding that to allow it to act against the unrepresented employee applicant would have created an unfair "imbalance".

Commissioner Cambridge said Serco had not met any of the three criteria in s596 of the Fair Work Act to justify legal representation.

He said the case was not sufficiently complex to require lawyers, and that Serco was not incapable of representing itself.

On the issue of fairness, the commissioner if he granted the employer permission for legal representation, "something of an imbalance would emerge whereby it would be represented by a lawyer while the applicant would be self represented".

"The resultant imbalance would create great potential for the absence of a fair and just Hearing as was identified by the Federal Court Judgment in the Warrell case," Commissioner Cambridge said.

The commissioner said s596 contained more stringent requirements for granting permission than under the former Workplace Relations Act 1996, citing Commissioner Greg Harrison's 2009 Rodgers ruling (see Related Article) and Commissioner John Lewin's 2011 Lekos decision (see Related Article).

Azzopardi v Serco Sodexo Defence Services Pty Limited [2013] FWC 3405 (29 May 2013)

Did you miss...

FWC to hear government HR manager's case

In a significant ruling on the FWC's jurisdictional reach, a HR manager has been given the all-clear to contest her sacking by Queensland Treasury after the State accepted it misled a member over the tribunal's powers to deal with state system employees. more

Bill extends NSW IRC appointment limits

New South Wales' Minns Government has introduced legislation it says will "ensure that the Industrial Relations Commission has the people, powers and practical arrangements needed to do its work properly", largely by making it easier to make acting appointments that can last for longer. more

Accountant bitten by short-term voluntary pay cut

An accountant who took a temporary $40,000 pay cut to help colleagues keep their jobs during a downturn has exceeded the high-income threshold for protection against unfair dismissal because of extra payments he later received to "recoup" the money. more

Workers' rights "underdone" in Human Rights Bill: Union

A Human Rights Bill that would require the NSW Government to consider human rights when developing legislation lacks a right to organise through trade unions and its consideration of workers is "underdone", a teachers' union has told a parliamentary inquiry. more